26 Christmas Desserts That Make Your Holiday Table Extra Special

Jump to Recipes ↓

1. 1Chocolate Crinkle Cookies
2. 2Snowball Cookies
3. 3Peanut Butter Blossoms
4. 4Red and Green M&M Cookies
5. 5Decorated Sugar Cookies
6. 6Shortbread S Cookies
7. 7Gingerbread Cookies
8. 8Chocolate Caramel Shortbread Bars
9. 9Mini Cheesecakes
10. 10Pumpkin Cheesecake
11. 11Apple Cider Donut Cake
12. 12Pumpkin Bread
13. 13Gingerbread Cake
14. 14Yule Log
15. 15Eggnog Bread Pudding
16. 16Churro Bread Pudding
17. 17Eggnog Panna Cotta
18. 18Raspberry Panna Cotta
19. 19Chocolate Mousse
20. 20Rice Pudding
21. 21Red Wine Poached Pears
22. 22Baked Cinnamon Apples
23. 23Mixed Berry Tart
24. 24Key Lime Pie
25. 25Pecan Pie
26. 26Apple Crisp

Table of Contents

1. 1How to Plan a Christmas Dessert Table Without Spending All Day Baking
2. 2Christmas Cookies and Bars for Holiday Trays
3. 3Christmas Cakes, Breads, and Cheesecakes
4. 4Christmas Puddings, Panna Cotta, and Creamy Desserts
5. 5Christmas Fruit Desserts and Holiday Pies
6. 6Which Christmas Desserts Should You Make Ahead?
7. 7How to Keep Christmas Desserts Fresh and Safe
8. 8How to Add Protein Without Ruining Christmas Desserts
9. 9Common Christmas Dessert Problems and How to Avoid Them
10. 10Frequently Asked Questions About Christmas Desserts
11. 11Final Thoughts

Christmas dessert should be something you look forward to, not another exhausting job on an already busy holiday. A few thoughtfully chosen sweets can make your table feel festive without requiring you to bake from morning until midnight.

The most appealing dessert spreads offer contrast: soft cookies beside crisp shortbread, rich chocolate beside tart fruit, and creamy chilled treats alongside something warm from the oven.

These 26 Christmas desserts cover cookies, cakes, cheesecakes, puddings, panna cotta, fruit desserts, and classic pies. You'll find practical preparation tips, make-ahead suggestions, and serving ideas to help you choose what works for your gathering.

Planning the savory side of your celebration, too? Browse our 27 Christmas Day Dinner Ideas for holiday menu inspiration.

How to Plan a Christmas Dessert Table Without Spending All Day Baking

Start by thinking about your guest count, available refrigerator space, and how you want to serve dessert.

For a casual gathering, cookies, bars, and mini cheesecakes let guests choose their own portions. For a sit-down dinner, one centerpiece dessert such as a Yule log or pumpkin cheesecake can make a stronger impression than several complicated recipes.

A practical dessert table includes:

• Something chocolatey: Chocolate crinkle cookies, chocolate mousse, or chocolate caramel shortbread bars.
• Something buttery or crisp: Snowball cookies, shortbread S cookies, or decorated sugar cookies.
• Something creamy: Mini cheesecakes, pumpkin cheesecake, or panna cotta.
• Something fruity: Mixed berry tart, baked cinnamon apples, or apple crisp.

You don't need to make all 26 recipes. Choose a few that complement one another, and give priority to desserts that can be prepared before Christmas Day.

Christmas Cookies and Bars for Holiday Trays

Cookies are especially useful during the holidays because they're easy to portion, share, and arrange on gift trays. A good assortment includes different textures and flavors rather than several versions of the same cookie.

If you want to organize your baking schedule around dough chilling requirements, see our 26 Christmas Cookies by Dough Rest Time.

1. Chocolate Crinkle Cookies

Chocolate crinkle cookies look like little snow-covered chocolate cakes. The dark, fudgy dough expands during baking, breaking through its powdered sugar coating to create the distinctive crackled finish.

Chilling the dough helps control spreading and makes the sticky mixture easier to handle. Roll each portion generously in powdered sugar for a more pronounced contrast.

Best for: Chocolate lovers, cookie exchanges, and festive dessert trays.

2. Snowball Cookies

These delicate butter cookies contain finely chopped nuts and are coated in powdered sugar. Their crumbly texture makes them a lovely contrast to chewy chocolate cookies.

Pecans give them a buttery flavor, while walnuts offer a slightly more robust taste. Rolling them in powdered sugar twice once warm and once cool helps create their snowy appearance.

Best for: Gift boxes, coffee breaks, and classic holiday cookie assortments.

3. Peanut Butter Blossoms

Peanut butter blossoms pair a soft, lightly sweet peanut butter cookie with a chocolate candy in the center.

Roll the dough in sugar before baking, then press the chocolate into each cookie immediately after it comes out of the oven. Let the chocolate firm up before stacking.

Best for: Family baking sessions and guests who love peanut butter and chocolate.

4. Red and Green M&M Cookies

These cheerful cookies get their Christmas colors from red and green candy-coated chocolates rather than elaborate icing.

A brown-sugar cookie base provides a chewy center and lightly golden edges. Save some candies for the tops so their festive colors remain visible.

Best for: Beginner bakers, children's parties, and last-minute cookie trays.

5. Decorated Sugar Cookies

Cut-out sugar cookies turn dessert preparation into a creative holiday activity. Stars, trees, and snowflakes can be decorated with royal icing in festive colors.

Roll the dough evenly, chill softened shapes before baking, and allow icing to dry thoroughly before stacking.

Best for: Decorating parties, edible gifts, and personalized holiday treats.

6. Shortbread S Cookies

Shortbread S cookies are simple, buttery treats shaped into elegant curves. They rely on a short ingredient list and careful mixing rather than elaborate toppings.

Bake until the edges are just lightly golden. Their tender, crumbly texture pairs especially well with tea or coffee.

Best for: Elegant cookie platters and guests who prefer less heavily decorated sweets.

7. Gingerbread Cookies

Molasses, ginger, cinnamon, and cloves give gingerbread cookies their recognizable Christmas flavor.

Chilled dough is easier to roll and cut cleanly. You can bake them slightly softer for eating or a little firmer for detailed decorating, depending on the recipe and thickness.

Best for: Holiday traditions, family decorating, and homemade gifts.

8. Chocolate Caramel Shortbread Bars

These rich bars combine a buttery shortbread base, a soft caramel center, and a smooth chocolate topping.

Each layer needs time to set before the next is added. Small squares are ideal because the combination is satisfyingly rich.

Best for: Dessert platters, gifting, and make-ahead holiday treats.

Christmas Cakes, Breads, and Cheesecakes

Cakes and cheesecakes bring a centerpiece element to the Christmas table. Many also benefit from being prepared ahead, allowing their flavors to settle and their textures to firm.

For additional seasonal baking inspiration, visit our 25 Easy Fall Dessert Recipes Everyone Will Love.

9. Mini Cheesecakes

Mini cheesecakes deliver the creamy richness of a traditional cheesecake without the need for slicing.

Bake them in lined muffin cups, chill thoroughly, and add berries or fruit topping before serving. Their individual portions make them convenient for buffets.

Best for: Parties, dessert tables, and gatherings where easy serving matters.

10. Pumpkin Cheesecake

Pumpkin cheesecake combines cream cheese, pumpkin puree, and warming spices over a buttery crumb crust.

A gingersnap crust adds extra holiday character. Allow the cheesecake to cool gradually and chill completely before slicing for the neatest presentation.

Best for: Make-ahead holiday centerpieces and pumpkin dessert fans.

11. Apple Cider Donut Cake

Apple cider donut cake captures the flavor of cinnamon-sugar donuts in a tender Bundt cake.

Reducing the apple cider concentrates its flavor, while a cinnamon-sugar coating gives the cake its familiar donut-inspired finish.

Best for: Christmas brunch, afternoon coffee, and holiday dessert buffets.

12. Pumpkin Bread

Pumpkin bread is a moist, warmly spiced quick bread that's easy to slice and share.

Walnuts or pecans add crunch, while chocolate chips make it sweeter. Avoid overmixing the batter so the loaf remains tender.

Best for: Make-ahead baking, gifting, and relaxed holiday gatherings.

13. Gingerbread Cake

Gingerbread cake brings molasses and warm spices into a soft, dark cake that can be cut into generous squares.

It doesn't require complicated decoration. A little whipped cream or a light dusting of powdered sugar is enough.

Best for: Serving a crowd and anyone who enjoys traditional Christmas spices.

14. Yule Log

A Yule log, or Bûche de Noël, is a rolled chocolate sponge cake filled with cream and covered in chocolate frosting or ganache.

The frosting can be textured to resemble tree bark, making the cake a festive centerpiece. Rolling the sponge according to the recipe's instructions helps prevent cracks.

Best for: Special Christmas dinners and impressive dessert presentations.

Christmas Puddings, Panna Cotta, and Creamy Desserts

Creamy desserts are especially helpful when oven space is limited. Several can be chilled in individual glasses and finished with simple toppings just before serving.

15. Eggnog Bread Pudding

Eggnog bread pudding transforms cubes of brioche into a rich, custardy dessert with the warm flavor of nutmeg.

Allow the bread time to absorb the eggnog mixture before baking. Serve warm with a little vanilla sauce or whipped cream.

Best for: Cozy Christmas dinners and using slightly stale brioche.

16. Churro Bread Pudding

Churro bread pudding combines a soft custard center with a cinnamon-sugar topping inspired by churros.

Day-old bread absorbs the custard well. Fresh berries can provide a pleasant contrast to the sweetness.

Best for: Warm holiday desserts and family-style serving.

17. Eggnog Panna Cotta

Eggnog panna cotta is a smooth, chilled dessert with a delicate wobble and subtle nutmeg flavor.

Gelatin gives it structure, so careful measuring is essential. Serving it in small glasses eliminates the need to unmold it.

Best for: Elegant make-ahead desserts and gatherings with limited oven space.

18. Raspberry Panna Cotta

Raspberry panna cotta pairs a creamy vanilla base with bright raspberry topping.

The red fruit against the pale cream makes it naturally festive. Chill the panna cotta completely before adding cooled raspberry sauce.

Best for: Individual desserts and a lighter-feeling finish after a rich meal.

19. Chocolate Mousse

Chocolate mousse is rich in flavor yet airy in texture.

Fold whipped cream gently into cooled melted chocolate to preserve the mousse's lightness. Serve in small glasses with chocolate shavings or berries.

Best for: Chocolate lovers and desserts that can be prepared ahead.

20. Rice Pudding

Rice pudding is a comforting combination of tender rice, milk, vanilla, and cinnamon.

Slow, gentle cooking creates a creamy texture. Stir regularly to prevent scorching, and serve either warm or chilled.

Best for: Traditional comfort desserts and simple pantry-based baking alternatives.

Christmas Fruit Desserts and Holiday Pies

Fruit desserts bring acidity, freshness, and color to a Christmas spread. They're particularly useful when the rest of the menu includes rich chocolate, cream, or caramel.

21. Red Wine Poached Pears

Red wine poached pears are an elegant dessert made by gently simmering firm pears with wine, sugar, citrus, and spices.

The pears take on a deep red color and can be served with a reduced poaching syrup.

Best for: Sophisticated holiday dinners and individually plated desserts.

22. Baked Cinnamon Apples

Baked cinnamon apples fill the kitchen with the aroma of warm fruit, brown sugar, butter, and spice.

Choose firm apples that can hold their shape. Chopped pecans add crunch, while vanilla ice cream makes the dessert especially comforting.

Best for: Easy warm desserts and smaller gatherings.

23. Mixed Berry Tart

A mixed berry tart combines crisp pastry, smooth pastry cream, and a colorful layer of fresh berries.

Prepare the crust and filling separately in advance, then assemble closer to serving to help the pastry stay crisp.

Best for: A colorful centerpiece and guests who enjoy fruit-forward desserts.

24. Key Lime Pie

Key lime pie adds a refreshing citrus note to a rich Christmas menu.

Its tangy filling and buttery graham cracker crust provide a contrast to spiced cakes and chocolate desserts. Chill thoroughly before slicing.

Best for: A bright, cool dessert after a substantial holiday meal.

25. Pecan Pie

Pecan pie is a classic holiday dessert with a sweet, rich filling and crunchy pecans.

Allow it to cool fully before cutting so the filling has time to set. Because it contains an egg-based filling, refrigerate it appropriately.

Best for: Traditional holiday dinners and make-ahead pies.

26. Apple Crisp

Apple crisp combines tender cinnamon-spiced apples with a golden, buttery oat topping.

It's easier to prepare than a traditional double-crust pie and especially satisfying when served warm.

Best for: Family-style desserts and a comforting finish to Christmas dinner.

Which Christmas Desserts Should You Make Ahead?

A little planning makes holiday baking much easier.

Two or more days ahead: Prepare suitable cookie doughs, bake cookies that store well, and organize dry ingredients for cakes and breads.

The day before: Make cheesecakes, panna cotta, mousse, and other chilled desserts. Prepare tart components separately if needed.

Christmas Day: Add delicate toppings, arrange cookie trays, and bake desserts that are best served warm.

For more ideas about choosing desserts by presentation and serving style, explore our 25 Thanksgiving Desserts by How You Serve Them.

How to Keep Christmas Desserts Fresh and Safe

Desserts containing perishable dairy, eggs, custard, or cream fillings need careful storage.

Keep cheesecakes, panna cotta, pastry cream, and cream-filled cakes refrigerated. For a long gathering, bring out smaller portions and replenish them rather than leaving the entire batch on the table.

Plain cookies and unfrosted cakes may have different storage needs depending on their ingredients.

For authoritative guidance, consult the FoodSafety.gov Cold Food Storage Chart and follow the specific recipe's storage instructions.

How to Add Protein Without Ruining Christmas Desserts

Not every dessert needs to be high in protein. However, ingredients such as milk, eggs, nuts, and yogurt naturally contribute some protein.

Greek yogurt can work in certain cheesecake or panna cotta recipes, but substitutions change moisture, acidity, and texture. Use a recipe specifically formulated for the substitution instead of replacing cream or cream cheese without testing.

For nutrition labels, calculate protein using the final ingredient quantities and actual serving sizes rather than relying on generic estimates.

Common Christmas Dessert Problems and How to Avoid Them

Cookies spread too much: Chill dough when instructed and measure flour accurately.

Cheesecake cracks: Avoid excessive mixing after adding eggs, overbaking, and sudden cooling.

Panna cotta doesn't set: Check gelatin measurements and allow enough chilling time.

Tart crust becomes soggy: Cool the crust fully and assemble closer to serving.

Apple crisp topping turns soft: Serve reasonably soon after baking for the best contrast between the fruit and topping.

Frequently Asked Questions About Christmas Desserts

What are the easiest Christmas desserts for beginners?

Red and green M&M cookies, pumpkin bread, baked cinnamon apples, and apple crisp are approachable choices that don't require elaborate decorating.

Which Christmas desserts are best for a crowd?

Cookies, gingerbread cake, pumpkin cheesecake, and apple crisp are practical because they're easy to portion.

Which Christmas desserts can I make the day before?

Cheesecakes, panna cotta, chocolate mousse, and many cakes are convenient make-ahead options when stored correctly.

How many desserts should I serve at Christmas?

For a small gathering, two or three contrasting desserts may be enough. For a larger party, consider one cookie assortment, one centerpiece dessert, and one fruit-based or chilled option.

Can Christmas cookies be frozen?

Many baked cookies freeze well, although icing and delicate decorations may affect the result. Check the individual recipe's freezing instructions.

How can I decorate a Christmas dessert table?

Use serving dishes of different heights, group desserts by type, and choose one centerpiece. Fresh berries and simple food-safe decorations can add festive color.

Final Thoughts

The best Christmas dessert table isn't necessarily the biggest. It's the one that offers a thoughtful mix of flavors, textures, and serving styles while leaving you time to enjoy the celebration.

Choose your favorites from these 26 Christmas desserts, prepare suitable recipes ahead, and finish with a warm or beautifully decorated dessert that makes the occasion feel special.

'); w.document.close(); w.focus(); w.setTimeout(function(){w.print()},350); }); })();